The client manifesto
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
Update: Mark Bennett (whose blog is very good, btw) adds to my list with the following:
- How might this affect my driver’s license?
- If I take this offer, what will my record show?
- What are the elements of the charge against me? How is the state going to prove each element?
- What is the next thing you need me to do to help you defend me?
- Can I have that in writing?
All points that we can agree with. All defendants must be aware of the collateral consequences of their conviction (legal or otherwise) and make their decision based on that awareness. I particularly like #4. If you have any information that will help your defense, tell your attorney!
Original post: There are plenty of “Advice to clients” posts out there that tell the clients to stfu. While I mostly agree with them, here are things I think clients should know and require of their attorneys:
- Has the state made any offers to me? - You need to know what the offers are, what you will be pleading to and whether it is a good idea. Don’t let the attorney just convey the offer to you and ask you to “accept or reject”. Ask for information. Why should I take it and why should I reject it? Ask. Make an informed decision. You will regret it later.
- Will I get credit for my pre-sentence confinement? - Clients are frequently held on bonds from the time of their arraignment and don’t get out. In most states, that time should be credited to their sentence. However, each state has different rules. Ask about them. If you don’t and your lawyer doesn’t know, then you might end up losing that credit. If the lawyer doesn’t give you a clear answer, state your concern on the record to the judge. Say: “Judge, I have been held since…. Will that time be credited to my sentence? I don’t want to lose that time.”
- Discuss your testimony - The decision to testify is ultimately yours, but your lawyer has the experience with conducting examinations. Make sure you go over your testimony beforehand. Not some three minute quickie version. Make your lawyer ask you the questions he will ask you on the stand, so you can be ready.
- Will I be eligible for parole? - The most frequently asked question is: “When will I get out?” Be more specific. Ask about parole. Ask about any other pre-discharge programs. What is the availability? Am I eligible?
- Have you filed my appeal? Ethical rules require an attorney to represent the client until the appeal paperwork is filed. Don’t lose your right to appeal. Discuss clearly with the attorney whether you want to appeal (put it in writing if you can) and make sure the appeal is filed.
There’s more, but that’s all I got right now. Thoughts?
Sphere: Related Content



Our Client Advisory Board has written and adopted a set of Client-Centered Representation Standards setting out 20 points under the heading “Clients Want a Lawyer Who–” View it at http://www.nysda.org/About_NYSDA/05_ClientCenteredStandards.pdf